MovieBytes WinningScripts
http://pageawards.com/
WinningScripts PRO
      Message Board| Contest Comments| Update Profile| WinningScripts|

Screenwriting Contest Discount Coupons

Subscribe to WinningScriptsPRO

Message Board

User Contest Comments Subscribe in an RSS Reader

Comments posted here are the opinion and responsibility of the author, and not MovieBytes. MovieBytes reserves the right to remove postings from invalid email addresses, or no-longer-valid email addresses.

Most Recent Comments (Newest comments first):

(Displaying records 2201 thru 2300 of 2709 records)

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kevin Holmes Author: Kevin Holmes Posted: 04/27/2006 01:31 AM
I would recommend that people not enter this contest. However, if they do enter, definitely do not pay an additional fee for an evaluation. Based upon the comments here, I am apparently not the only person who did not receive their evaluation. There seems to be a trend towards people not receivng the evaluations that they paid for. I paid the additional $15 fee, made two polite requests for the evaluation (both after the winner was announced) but never received even a response, much less an evaluation. Perhaps a name change to FindThePhony might be in order.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Screenplay Festival[Post New Comment re: Screenplay Festival]

James Edwards Author: James Edwards Posted: 04/14/2006 02:54 PM
April 14, 2006: I have now received my coverage AND a refund -due to lateness. The coverage was very good, highlighting an area of the screenplay that I had not considered relevant, previously.

Therefore, I withdraw the negative and sarcastic comments I made above. While the miscommunication may have been on Screenplay Festival's part, the antagonistic response was my own. And, as I said before, while their lateness in answering was aggravating, this seems to be standard in contests nowadays. I certainly wouldn't want to discourage them from con-tinuing their coverage program, as this is really the only way the writer can be sure what he's sent in is actually being read.

My apologies, and next time I'll complain more than once before making a negative comment.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Screenplay Festival[Post New Comment re: Screenplay Festival]

James Edwards Author: James Edwards Posted: 04/08/2006 04:45 PM
While it's still fortunate I didn't hold my breath, I HAVE received word from Contest Coordinator Rick Reynolds that my screenplay was one of three that slipped through the cracks, being sent to the judges before being covered, and that coverage would come through this Monday (Apr 10). If this is the case, then I will retract the harsh words of my initial posts - all the more so since this is not the only contest with a time lag problem.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Slamdance[Post New Comment re: Slamdance]

LAUREN PETERSON Author: LAUREN PETERSON Posted: 04/07/2006 04:17 PM
You mean Scamdance??? I entered on deadline day. WORST contest I ever entered- and the most expensive. Entered a script that semifinaled in a big contest, made the top ten percent at Austin and top ten list on Triggerstreet. I thought it would at least place at Slamdance and the coverage would help me tweak it into a winner. The reader obviously rushed/skimmed/didn't give a damn or English was her second language. I was shocked. Phone consultation wasn't even offered- I wish it was. I complained to the director- he apologized, said she was a "new reader" for them, that I could re-enter the script and he'd read it--for another 75 bucks! No thanks.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: WriteMovies[Post New Comment re: WriteMovies]

Vincent Rocchio Author: Vincent Rocchio Posted: 04/05/2006 11:34 AM
I find it hard to believe that there would be any positive comments about this contest. Two words: "Competition Mill". Writemovies especially taught me a valuable lesson. If you go to a competition's website and cannot find the one you entered because there are so many contests there STAY AWAY. Writemovies is the quintessential take your money and run contest. I made it to the finals of this competition, and never once received individual notification that I was advancing in the competition. I had to find out on the internet searching for the site where I had placed in another competition. As with many competitions, Writemovies is not about finding scripts nearly as much as it is creating a sales and marketing database. They flood your email with services and other things to buy. Who needs it?

They like to present themselves as being "all about the writer". Yeah? Well how's this for sensitivity to writers. After receiving no notice from them for the entire competition, I looked in my email one day and found a message header: "And the Winner of the WriteMOvies Competition is..." Then you open up the message to find out that you did not win. Now, think about that. Of 70 finalists, 69 are going to open that message only to be disappointed. That's sensitive?

And the other thing about this contest that others found so positive should really be a warning to others. I lost out to a book, and not only that, a book written in another language. How dumb is that? A screenplay is at best, only a blueprint. Its never really going to be able to hold its own against a book. Now, if a competition wants to open itself up to other forms of writing, great, make categories, duh....But having screenplays compete against books strikes me as particularly not very involved in assessing and comparing the submissions. For a reason: this competition is not about scriptwriting, it's about making money. Stay away.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Fade In[Post New Comment re: Fade In]

Vincent Rocchio Author: Vincent Rocchio Posted: 04/05/2006 11:22 AM
I entered this year's Fade-In contest--2005. Although I received notice in the mail that I made it to the Quarter-Finals, that was the last notice I received, and the contest missed it's deadline by a fairly outrageous amount of time: deadline was Nov. 15 and winners were to be announced by Feb.15. They did not even get around to announcing the semi-finalists until the first week of April. Yeah, that's pretty lame. Rather than look at that in moral terms, though, I think the potential entrant should look at the consistent deadline problems this competition has in business terms. Like many contests, this is conducted as a marketing strategy and as part of a competition mill. Any organization running more than one contest a year is, in my view, not a contest to enter. They are more interested in you for your marketing and cash potential than your writing potential. There are plenty of really big, once a year script writing contests that are only that: contests. Not part of some writing or media business looking to improve cash flow.

Any contest is going to have good posts from people who scored big. The true measure, to my mind, is the people who did well but did not win prizes. How were they treated? With no feedback, no personal notice, no apologies for lateness, and fairly rude response when I made an inquiry, I conclude that this contest is not run well or for the sake of finding good scripts, but to make money. Stay away. I know I will.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Vincent Rocchio Author: Vincent Rocchio Posted: 03/15/2006 07:16 PM
I have to say I'm one of those people who are going to line up with the "amatuer hour" perspective on this contest. I submitted a very un-hollywood, Antonioni-esque script that was also highly political and received no feedback. Since feedback was supposed to be the upside of this contest, that pretty much sinks it in my opinion. So this contest treats a couple people really well. Big deal. For me it was a typical contest that took my money and I never heard from again except to hear that I lost. This contest has gotten a lot of points from people as being very "writer friendly". Take that with a grain of salt. It is clearly a one-man show and is not for those who are experimenting with narrative forms.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Vincent Rocchio Author: Vincent Rocchio Posted: 03/15/2006 07:03 PM
I didn't think much of this contest. First, it's not clear to me why two organizations are combining for a contest. This is the first contest out of 3 others that my script did NOT make it out of the first round. Hey, it happens, but I have to say, I'm not eager to enter any contest that fills my email with their "workshops" and other things for me to buy. Sorry, no. I'm interested in winning contests and advancing my work, not purchasing services. I'm also suspicious of any contest that asks for "anonymous" feedback before the competition is over. Coincidentally, I gave them very negative feedback. That's just coincidence though. All I got out of this contest was junk email. I'm completely unimpressed.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: PAGE International[Post New Comment re: PAGE International]

Annie S. Cian Author: Annie S. Cian Posted: 03/15/2006 05:13 PM
I have been so impressed at their professional conduct in the past that I have entered another script in the 2006 competition and once more I must say I am not disappointed. If it is possible they have become more forthcoming and extremely helpful in their handling and communicating skills, which in itself is very encouraging and confidence building for an author. A week ago I submitted a few questions to them and within the hour I received my reply. At the same time I forwarded the same queries to another contest organizers who always advertise in the front pages of the Movie Bytes, and I am still waiting for an answer. Ironically they always sent me number of e-mails every week to remind me of their deadline. That gives me a lot of food for thought in regards to their way of conducting these competitions. I would like to stress that this is the difference that makes PAGE invaluable to me.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Kairos Prize[Post New Comment re: Kairos Prize]

Graham Moes Author: Graham Moes Posted: 03/14/2006 10:10 PM
More than just a contest, the Kairos Prize is backed by two major, well-established, well-funded entities with bona fide contacts in the industry -- dozens of which were present at the awards ceremony. I entered two scripts -- one went far, one didn't, but the feedback even on the rejected project was thorough and professional. Highly recommended in all respects.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Heather Hughes Author: Heather Hughes Posted: 03/14/2006 09:19 PM
This contest accepted my script and check and then suddenly the screenplay part of the contest dissapeared. I emailed and got no response.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Kairos Prize[Post New Comment re: Kairos Prize]

david anthony Author: david anthony Posted: 03/14/2006 09:03 PM
I find it interesting that any opinion other than favorable could be given of this contest at this point since it is in its first year. Time will tell if it will aid in the advancement of careers. Regardless, my experience with this contest has been great and I'm glad it exists, if only to give Christians a voice in Hollywood.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Screenplay Festival[Post New Comment re: Screenplay Festival]

James Edwards Author: James Edwards Posted: 03/13/2006 12:18 PM
3/13/06: Still have heard zilch from Screenplay Festival about my screenplay "gOD's mAn". I will post if and when the coverage arrives. Needless to say, I'm not holding my breath.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: 20/20[Post New Comment re: 20/20]

Harry Bauer Author: Harry Bauer Posted: 03/09/2006 10:29 PM
When you enter multiple contests, every dollars adds up, esp. when you are an admin. assistant by day... "sheesh!" to the prior comment of lighten up! I should have read these comments before I entered. The contest feedback comments were reserved to a few scribbles. One comment made it clear that the reader was not very perceptive. Stay away from this contest! I got a 'no' for having three dimensional characters, and yet my nerdy leads weren't allowed to "stroll" as a form of walking because a "hyper character wouldn't stroll" Hmmm... would you call that a one-dimensional character or a three-dimensional character? I did get a handy list of walking verbs. Was that worth $20? I don't know. You tell me.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Contest of Contest Winners[Post New Comment re: Contest of Contest Winners]

Anita Skibski Author: Anita Skibski Posted: 03/08/2006 08:04 PM
If you qualify to enter this contest, you're taking on the best of the best. And if you make the top ten, people take notice. I've gotten four script requests since the results were posted. Keep your eye on this one.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

cindy keller Author: cindy keller Posted: 03/04/2006 05:48 PM
I was a winner in their 2005 Contest with my script, "Tattoo". I received my copy of the DVD, "Boneyard Tales III", in the mail two days ago.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Big Bear[Post New Comment re: Big Bear]

SHARON SHIPLEY Author: SHARON SHIPLEY Posted: 03/01/2006 11:26 AM
I TOO FOUND THE BIG BEAR SCREENPLAY COMMENTS, TOO BRIEF SNIDE AND SHALLOW, PARTICULARLY SINCE THE VERY SAME SCRIPT, SARY'S GOLD, WON THE SCRIPT PIMP GRAND PRIZE NOT TWO MONTHS BEFORE.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Writers Place[Post New Comment re: Writers Place]

Donald Rosenblit Author: Donald Rosenblit Posted: 02/28/2006 12:44 PM
HOORAY…My screen play ROD WEILER PRIVATE EYE DOG IN PLAY DEAD was the 3rd prize winner of The Writers Place 2005 screenplay competition. I think that the best thing that I can say about The Writers Place is that they made me feel like I was the only one that entered their contest. They could not have been more pleasant. They were very professional but at the same time made me feel like an old friend. Their response to several of my e-mails was immediate and helpful. Then they proceeded to provide me wonderful feedback that will help make my 3rd prize winning script a 1st prize winning script the next time around.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: 20/20[Post New Comment re: 20/20]

Anita Skibski Author: Anita Skibski Posted: 02/27/2006 06:46 PM
Tedious excuses for their incredibly long judging period. They only charge 20 dollars because they're only reading 20 pages of your script. Feedback was useless and convoluted. My scripts are doing great elsewhere.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Valley International[Post New Comment re: Valley International]

Stefan Stenudd Author: Stefan Stenudd Posted: 02/27/2006 03:51 AM
They seem to have no system of quarter and semi finalists. Their website gives the same six script names for "Official selection" and "Category Award Nominees". That's a bore. On the other hand, although my script is not among them, I have to say that the chosen scripts seem to be quite interesting.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Acclaim Film[Post New Comment re: Acclaim Film]

James Ossi Author: James Ossi Posted: 02/25/2006 11:25 AM
Gadzooks, I didn't win again. Well, shoot.

But, oddly, Frank Drouzas's comments on my script were accurate and helpful, actually. Furthermore, unlike feedback from other competitions, his many criticisms weren't insulting. He never uses words like "idiot" or "moron." This, for me, is a step up, is a compliment. And I am thrilled. Thanks Frank. You're okay.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Extreme Feature[Post New Comment re: Extreme Feature]

candace brasseur Author: candace brasseur Posted: 02/24/2006 07:34 PM
Great feedback, concise and very specific. It is evident that a great deal of time is spent on each script entry. Email notifications were always on time and encouraging. A very enjoyable experience.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Eric Blakkestad Author: Eric Blakkestad Posted: 02/20/2006 07:58 PM
They don't just beat the competition, they CRUSH IT!!! I mean, this is feedback at it's best! This is take no prisoners, firing on all cylinders, we're blowing our competitors out of the water like it's friggin' Pearl Harbor folks!

To put it more mildly, phenomenal coverage. They not only thoughtfully read my script but digested the material and came back with outstanding advice on theme, character arc, dialogue and lots more. I'm grateful to these wonderful ladies for the marvelous treatment and positive reinforcement, feedback and coverage I received on my story.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Heather Hughes Author: Heather Hughes Posted: 02/16/2006 05:09 PM
I had to write this in response to the other comments on this film festival. I am a first time screenwriter. I entered the SDFF with no prior experience, no studio connection, and no agent. My script Zig Zag placed in the top ten at this festival. I received a wonderful phone message from Joel Eisenberg, the director of the contest, congratulating me and wishing me good luck. (I still have the message saved on my answering machine becuase it was such a gracious and lovely touch.) Although I did not win Joel has been accessible and helpful since the contest. He has started an email group for screenwriters to share their questions and ideas and continues months after the contest to be gracious to all with his time and encouragement.

I highly encourage you to enter this contest!!!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Acclaim Film[Post New Comment re: Acclaim Film]

Richard Haber Author: Richard Haber Posted: 02/10/2006 12:34 PM
I was the winner of this contest and I found the reader's report quite interesting and smart, with constructive criticism and suggestions that will certainly be helpful in a future rewriting.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Anita Skibski Author: Anita Skibski Posted: 02/06/2006 09:50 AM
Simply the best coverage anywhere. They give detailed and knowledgeable notes on your entire script, because they READ the entire script. The personal attention, the clear desire to HELP you, and the perceptive comments on a script make this competition a Do Not Miss.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Screenplay Festival[Post New Comment re: Screenplay Festival]

James Edwards Author: James Edwards Posted: 02/04/2006 09:39 AM
Sent screenplay "gOD's mAN" for Screenplay Festival contest coverage, shortly before Sept. 1, 2005. Followed up mid-December. Reply: "We're busy. Be patient." Well into February, still no response. Ergo, I post this comment: Avoid Screenplay Festival at all costs.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Ronald Vincent Author: Ronald Vincent Posted: 02/02/2006 10:05 PM
Feeding Frenzy provides detailed coverage that strengthens the focus, the theme, and the heart of a story. They understand writers and have a gift for sharing insights that make a script better in every dimension. I have recommended this competition to my closest friends who are writers.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Massimo Park Author: Massimo Park Posted: 01/31/2006 09:37 PM
As a beginning writer, i've only entered 4 screenwriting contests, including the Brass Brad, but i've found that all the other contests i entered also extended their deadlines, so i'm beginning to think this is the norm, which makes sense if one considers the fact that when a contest posts their deadline info, they do so blindly, i.e. without knowing exactly how many entries they will have. so, if they are suddenly overwhelmed, can we blame them?

i think we can only place blame if the contest doesn't have the courtesy to inform their contestants that there have been delays, which was NOT the case with the Brass Brad.

in fact, i received a personal call from the founder of the contest, Kimberly, notifying me of the delay (not sure if this was because i was a semi-finalist, but it sure was nice, especially considering that i live in Toronto, Canada, so it was a long-distance call for Kimberly who lives in California).

although i didn't place as a winner/finalist, the personal phone interview i had with Kimberly provided me with many insights, and the judge's scorecard i received was very helpful in steering me in the right direction with regards to revisions.

perhaps the best comment i can make about this contest is that it's NOT some way for Kimberly to push contestants into spending money. yes, she sends us promotional material, but this is de rigeur as they are her sponsors. i think Kimberly is genuinely interested in helping out her writers, and i am looking forward to entering the mentorship for 2006.

thanks, massimo

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Joel Doty Author: Joel Doty Posted: 01/28/2006 07:23 PM
I received much better comments from this contest than I did from a "paid reader" I even received additional coverage beyond what I paid for because the reader felt my script had so much potential. Definately worth every penny.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Tina Juarez Author: Tina Juarez Posted: 01/27/2006 05:53 PM
The quality and detail of the feedback I received on my script was at such a level I felt I was enrolled in a graduate level seminar in screenwriting! And the encouragement from Molly was so genuine, so heartfelt and personal, I truly believe she is one of those rare people whose greatest joy is helping other people realize their dreams.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Kelly Parks Author: Kelly Parks Posted: 01/27/2006 01:07 PM
Amazing coverage! I'd had dozens of people look at my screenplay and I'd received a variety of vague comments but Cheryl & Molly did what no one else had done: they told me specifically what I was doing wrong. That's the feedback you need if you really want to sell your work.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Fred Miller Author: Fred Miller Posted: 01/24/2006 01:02 AM
My experience with BlueCat was extremely positive. I received written feedback which I thought was well-thought out and constructive. I feel that it was an excellent opportunity to get some comments on a script that I had been working on for awhile, with little to no feedback. I would recommend anyone who wants to try out a contest, that this would be a good one to try out.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Extreme Feature[Post New Comment re: Extreme Feature]

David Bertoni Author: David Bertoni Posted: 01/18/2006 07:09 PM
Incredibly helpful notes. Not a lot of empty fluff. Hard hitting and helpful. Worth the cost of admission alone.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Bret Ootes Author: Bret Ootes Posted: 01/16/2006 04:28 PM
Cheryl and Molly were extremely professional in their critique of my screenplay, ATOMIC EYE. I am currently working on a rewrite and their words of encouragement have already come in handy. It means a lot to any writer just to have his work read let alone to have professional guidance. Once again, thank you for all your help. Bret Ootes.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: PAGE International[Post New Comment re: PAGE International]

Harvey Papush Author: Harvey Papush Posted: 01/11/2006 03:51 PM
I entered in 2005 and did not place but, like other posters, I was impressed with the fast, personal and concerned responses from Ms. Berg to emailed questions. More importantly, their professional feedback, which I've purchased from them for three screenplays independent of the contest, is extremely helpful, honest, professional, and reasonably priced.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kimberly Seilhamer Author: Kimberly Seilhamer Posted: 01/10/2006 10:35 PM
The notification deadline was pushed to December -- as stated on the website and on our phone message system. This was necessary to accommodate the judges. This information was posted the first week of November. Semi-finalists were notified via phone (or email if necessary)in November and December.

We have strived to provide each writer with a positive, supportive, and personal experience. All emails were answered in a timely manner and any phone messages were returned within 48 hours.

Sincerely,

Kimberly Seilhamer Founder The Brass Brad Screenwriting Mentorship Award '06

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Gabriella Messina Author: Gabriella Messina Posted: 01/06/2006 10:11 PM
Since I always enter contests, not with the expectation of winning but with the assurance that someone is going to read my script, I consider every contest entry to be a success in and of itself. I found my experience with this contest to be extremely positive. I appreciated the timely notifications of receiving my script and, to my utter delight and amazement, notification of my winning Third Place this year. Not bad for my first script/ first contest, if I do say so myself. I was not able to personally be there at the film festival to receive my award, but I was very impressed by the kindness and amiability of the contest organizers, in particular Mr. Jonathan Lipp, in seeing to it that I received my plaque, etc., at my convenience. I would rate my overall experience as positive and would certainly not discourage anyone from sending their script to this, or any other, contest.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Mike Murphy Author: Mike Murphy Posted: 01/06/2006 04:06 PM
This competition surpassed all my expectations. I received ten pages of extensive notes that went into the details of my story. Cheryl and Molly put forth the extra effort that makes their contest stand tall in a field of many. If you are going to invest your money in a contest, than I suggest you put A Feeding Frenzy at the top of your list.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Contest of Contest Winners[Post New Comment re: Contest of Contest Winners]

Mike Murphy Author: Mike Murphy Posted: 01/06/2006 01:59 PM
I echo the comments of Ken. I truly believe this competition will grow into one of the more prestigious contests. I have already received four requests from producers and management companies. Getting read is what it's all about.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Scriptapalooza[Post New Comment re: Scriptapalooza]

Mike McGeever Author: Mike McGeever Posted: 12/10/2005 12:02 AM
As a finalist (top 30) in the 2005 contest my experience was a good one. Results were prompt and communications clear. It seems a number of the winners have gotten options, agents, or notice. Congratulations!! Negatives? I didn't receive any requests for my script, so other than making me feel GREAT it didn't accomplish much. I was hoping that making it to the top 1% might attract more notice. My opinion? With 4,000 competitors the chances that any one script will come out on the very top are small, but the payoff is big enough for the 5 or 10 that do that it is a worthwhile lottery ticket. I would enter Scriptapalooza again, and I'm grateful that my script was considered. Thank you Scriptapalooza!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Timothy Kernc Author: Timothy Kernc Posted: 12/02/2005 07:36 PM
I was pleasantly surprised at the length of coverage and detailed notes I received for my winning script, LIVE NOT ON EVIL. The professionalism, communication, and willingness to talk with me were truly refreshing in this highly competitive and typically impersonal world of amateur screenwriting. It's nice to see a contest actually meet their dates and commitments.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: 20/20[Post New Comment re: 20/20]

Phil Clarke Author: Phil Clarke Posted: 11/24/2005 09:47 AM
I entered and was a finalist in this competition once and will not enter again. They start up the next contestbefore they finish judging the previous one. The feedback I received had mistakes in it, some which I feel affected the judge's opinion One such mistake stated that I should have introduced a particular character earlier than page 56; the character was introduced on page 6. I e-mailed the competition people about this, but never received a reply.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: FilmMakers[Post New Comment re: FilmMakers]

David Campbell Author: David Campbell Posted: 11/21/2005 10:28 AM
A very positive experience. With Filmmakers Int'l, I know I'm on the right track because my submitted script was judged to be in about the top 3%. With some other contests, there's no feedback; it's Pass/Fail only.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

John Dart Author: John Dart Posted: 11/16/2005 09:29 PM
My writing partner and I were Grand Prize winners of this contest in 2004. I can say without a doubt that we had a positive experience. All prizes were awarded as advertised and in a timely manner including an expenses paid trip to the Austin Film Festival and a two page write up on us in Writer's Digest magazine. We received quite a few requests from producers, etc. after they announce the winners. We are re-entering the 2005 contest based on our experience in 2004. This is a very legit contest/organization.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Jeff Williams Author: Jeff Williams Posted: 11/09/2005 09:28 AM
I would hestitate to enter any "one page" type contests, gang. Truly, what can you tell about a story in one page that could possibly win a contest? Much better rewards would come from sending your one page to reputable agents and producers and let them decide on its value. Just my two cents...

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Red Inkworks [Post New Comment re: Red Inkworks ]

steven arvanites Author: steven arvanites Posted: 11/07/2005 11:50 PM
I just got 3rd place in the present competition. YAHOO! Even if I came in 309th place, this is a quality competition. The notes I recieved were worth $100's. Larry is quality. And a great creative bargin. I'm a fan for life. It's all about his well written, thoughtful and smart notes, guys!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kyle Sullivan Author: Kyle Sullivan Posted: 11/02/2005 02:58 AM
When I entered a different competition offered through scr(i)pt magazine, I was informed of my progress. I didn't make it then, but I felt good about the whole process. But THIS time? I'm still waiting to be notified that I didn't even place in this contest; I found out my status when Moviebytes posted their press release. I expected better...which is probably my own damn fault. Won't happen again.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kyle Sullivan Author: Kyle Sullivan Posted: 10/28/2005 03:01 AM
Now this was a well-run competition. I was kept updated on my progress, and the Expo itself is a wonderful off-shoot of the contest. I may not have won, but I feel like the people involved gave my script a decent chance. In fact, I'd have liked some feedback on it from them; they really seem to know what they're doing. So much so, I'm attending the upcoming Expo in November...and I hate going to those things.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Indie Gathering[Post New Comment re: Indie Gathering]

Kyle Sullivan Author: Kyle Sullivan Posted: 10/28/2005 02:56 AM
This competition was well-run and everything happened when they said it would. I only received an "Honorable Mention" laurel for my script, which was posted online, but I still felt good about the overall experience. I don't know how much the festival will help my script get made, but it certainly won't hurt it.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Horror/Sci-Fi[Post New Comment re: Horror/Sci-Fi]

Kyle Sullivan Author: Kyle Sullivan Posted: 10/27/2005 03:11 PM
I sent a newly rewritten script into this competition just to see what would happen. To be honest, I didn't really expect it to go anywhere (its hero is gay and it has major religious overtones), but neither did I expect to be completely ignored by the people running this competition. I have yet to receive notification of the results, and the last time I checked they hadn't even listed on their website. I learned the reults only because they HAD notified MovieBytes.com. Not only is that unprofessional, it's exptremely impolite.

I'm hoping this happened because they're new to this and don't realize the importance of simple updates or even specified time frames for when competition decisions are made, and is not because of the subject matter. It's not like they're the only ones to pull this nonsense; I'm still waiting to hear back from "scr(i)pt magazine" about when the finalists will be announced for a horror competition they offered but which is not even posted on their website...and they've been doing these contests for years. So I guess we'll see how things go...but I'm not bothering with the IHSFS Competition, again.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Mike McGeever Author: Mike McGeever Posted: 10/24/2005 06:33 PM
There was some delay in the notification, and I was confused at first because I got a message that I had lost and later a message I had won. One critic liked my script and another hated it, but I thought all of the criticism was constructive and (more importantly) instructive. I got a strong sense of what didn't work for them, and I did feel like the reviews were thoughtful and not rushed or sloppy.

I finished in the top 30, so I made neither the top 3 or the top 10, but I thought the critique and the very nice e-mails I got from the contest director made this a very worthwhile experience. I was a loser, but the feedback gave me something concrete to work on.

I also thought the "party with the agents" approach was novel, and although I couldn't attend I appreciated the unique chance this gives you to sell your work.

As a side note, they did say an agency wanted to see the loglines for some of the top 30 scripts, so even "losers" such as myself got a second bite of the apple, which was, I thought, very nice of them.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Jay Natelle Author: Jay Natelle Posted: 10/21/2005 12:49 PM
The coverage was stimulating and provocative. I could tell that they had put their hearts and minds into it. Their sensitivity to the vulnerability of a writer in front of criticism is, in my opinion, a very important aspect of the quality of the notes given. I had the feeling that the comments they made were about my script and where I seemed to be going with it and not about the script that they would have written had they been me. Thanks ever so much to Cheryl & Molly.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Red Inkworks [Post New Comment re: Red Inkworks ]

Jorge J. Lomastro Author: Jorge J. Lomastro Posted: 10/13/2005 06:22 PM
Ah... It's so nice, though rare, to be able to say this about a contest. I RECOMMEND it highly. You go, Larry!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Jorge J. Lomastro Author: Jorge J. Lomastro Posted: 10/13/2005 06:11 PM
Put simply, do yourself and all other writers a favor. PASS on this contest. There are plenty of reputable contests available to spend your money on.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: hollywoodscript.com [Post New Comment re: hollywoodscript.com ]

gary mangelsdorf Author: gary mangelsdorf Posted: 10/12/2005 06:00 PM
One word desribes the professionalism and dedication of Craig and Judy Kellem -- incredible. They are tireless in their work and brutally honest in their opinions. But in a good way! They'll keep working with you until you get it right. You couldn't ask for a better script consultant than these two. Their credentials obviously speak for themselves. Lucky for us they're even available! Gary Mangelsdorf

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Cheryl Compton Author: Cheryl Compton Posted: 10/12/2005 03:05 PM
I agree with Trish 100%. It was less than 3 weeks from the day I mailed the application and script to the day I got a "thanks but no thanks" email. Our script has done quite well in many contests, so I'm very surprised by their quick elimination. Live and learn. Don't waste your money. There are many better run contests.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Acclaim Film[Post New Comment re: Acclaim Film]

Larry N Stouffer Author: Larry N Stouffer Posted: 10/06/2005 12:08 PM
I entered and did not place. When I do place in a contest I always say I caught a good reader. When I do not place I say I caught a poor reader. You know where this is going... The notes I got - and I must say that to get notes at all is a plus, as most contests send you nothing - were extremely weak. My thinking is whomever sent them is relatively inexperienced in the craft. So be it. Obviously you aren't going to get a real pro doing this stuff or the entrance fee would be unapproachable for most screenwriters. Do I recommend this competition? No. Do I suggest you avoid it? No. I only recommend you not have high expectations. And don't take the notes too seriously.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: IndieProducer iP[Post New Comment re: IndieProducer iP]

Dan Wedeking Author: Dan Wedeking Posted: 10/03/2005 01:28 PM
I was wondering if anyone got anything out of this other than getting to attend a big gala? Anyone get an option or representation? Let me know (getting to attend a big gala isn't reason enough to enter a contest - if something that advanced your career as a result of your placement is)

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: IndieProducer iP[Post New Comment re: IndieProducer iP]

Jennifer Brasher Author: Jennifer Brasher Posted: 09/26/2005 05:30 PM
My screenplay Lonely Teardrops had the honor of placing 2nd this year, and IP had a fabulous awards ceremony in Beverly Hills (Feb 2005, the Fri night before the Academy Awards). All I can say is WOW, what an evening! I've been to several other award ceremonies this year, and none could touch this one in professionalism or glamour. Truly a lifetime hightlight for me. Plus Kerry was extremely helpful and got me meetings with an agent and manager. This contest is definitely worth entering.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kyle Sullivan Author: Kyle Sullivan Posted: 09/25/2005 08:02 PM
1. They kept delaying the notification date -- first it was Sept, 1st then the 20th then the evening of 24th and wound up being the morning of.

2. They didn't get the name of my script right, at all from what I can tell.

3. Feedback won't be coming till two months AFTER the notification date. Somehow, I don't expect it to be worthwhile.

4. When they finally informed everyone as to the what, when, how and where of the seminars that you get to attend for free just by entering, all of them have been offered elsewhere.

Listen, I've won several competitions and lost probably five times as many, but this is the first time I felt like I was being dissed by the people running things. I mean, seriously -- how hard is it to make sure you got the title of the script correct in the notification you're sending to the writer?

My advice, spend your money on a competition that has a real track record -- like the nicholl or Chesterfield or even the Writer's Digest series.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: IndieProducer iP[Post New Comment re: IndieProducer iP]

Beverly Abbott Author: Beverly Abbott Posted: 09/25/2005 11:58 AM
I was a top ten finalist and thought that the event was ran very professionally. The buzz that was created from this sort of event was amazing and my filmmates and myself were able to meet oscar winning actors, writers, producers, and directors in the biz who congratulated us on our success. This contest is a wonderful opportunity.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: IndieProducer iP[Post New Comment re: IndieProducer iP]

James Watts Author: James Watts Posted: 09/17/2005 08:26 PM
My script had the honor of winning third place in the 2004 Indieproducer Screenwriting Contest. The top ten were invited to the IP annual awards ceremony. We screenwriters were treated on equal footing with the film makers who were being honored that night as well. Andy Garcia was on hand to receive the IP’s top award, and he gave a spellbinding speech describing his creative journey. A real inspiration. A major part of the night’s events were devoted to the Screenwriting Contest results, and when my name was called and went up to get my award, I was definitely the deer caught in the headlights. Kerry David was totally accessible during the whole process and I am still in contact with her. Enter the contest, It’s one of the few that are worth it.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: IndieProducer iP[Post New Comment re: IndieProducer iP]

John Simpson Author: John Simpson Posted: 09/16/2005 04:54 PM
In November 2004 I entered my screenplay LUDWIG THE GREAT into the IP 2004 Contest. It was only one of two I chose to enter, specifically because of the stellar qualifications of judges such as Clark Peterson, the producer of MONSTER. I knew if I made it past that formidable gauntlet I might actually have talent after all. Might as well start at the top, right? In January of 2005 my entry was selected as a Top Ten Finalist, and I was invited to attend the IP 2004 Awards Gala at the Writers' Guild Theater in Beverly Hills (you know, swimmin' pools, movie stars?) this past February 25. My experience at that Gala was one of the highlights of my life. In addition to the five-star catering and open bar, I met actors Andy Garcia and Bruce Davison, screenwriter Barry Blaustein, who works very closely with Eddie Murphy and penned one of my all-time screwball comedies, Police Acedemy 2, as well as Kerry David, the Big Cheese at Indieproducer who also produced both Agent Cody Banks movies. She and IP also know how to throw one hell of a party! Words really can't tell the whole story of what a great experience it was for me, other than it was one I will never forget as long as I live. I cannot recommend strongly enough for any aspiring scribe to place their entry into this competition. I am entering yet another script with IP this year and would love to go again.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Devi Snively Author: Devi Snively Posted: 09/13/2005 12:58 PM
Wow! I know not my status in this competition as it's still going on, but I just got the (very prompt) feedback from my screenplay and was beyond impressed. This is the most constructive and helpful criticism I have ever received on a screenplay. Not only did they point out both strengths and weaknesses of the script, but they also offered helpful suggestions to improve it and so much more (they even found a typo that nobody else has caught to date). Definitely worth the entry fee. I have paid more for much lesser coverage in the past. Very professional, very friendly and very helpful. I wish I could afford to submit all of my screenplays to them.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Red Inkworks [Post New Comment re: Red Inkworks ]

Harry Bauer Author: Harry Bauer Posted: 09/13/2005 11:20 AM
The reason to enter this contest: feedback, quality feedback.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Cynthia Perkins Author: Cynthia Perkins Posted: 09/08/2005 10:29 PM
The coverage well exceeded my expectations. It was thorough, in depth and encouraging. Molly has an incredibile ability to zero in on the story you want to tell and offer very helpful suggestions. She goes above and beyond the call of duty. The coverage really set my creativity on fire as well. I couldn't be more pleased and I highly recommend them.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: WriteMovies[Post New Comment re: WriteMovies]

Christopher Canole Author: Christopher Canole Posted: 09/07/2005 02:06 PM
I was a monthly winner back in May 2005 and I am delighted to report the people who run this contest are still in contact with me trying to make sure their contest winner finds a producer who will turn my screenplay into a movie.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Acclaim Film[Post New Comment re: Acclaim Film]

Christopher Canole Author: Christopher Canole Posted: 09/06/2005 11:35 PM
I received honest and very usable comments on my winning script in a timely fashion which I will use in my next rewrite.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kurt Segers Author: Kurt Segers Posted: 09/04/2005 04:45 AM
doesn't sound fair to me: they can automatically option your script for only 1000$!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: 20/20[Post New Comment re: 20/20]

SKIN MEAD Author: SKIN MEAD Posted: 09/03/2005 11:17 PM
I was extremely disappointed with the feedback, or should I say, lack of feedback. My screenplay was a finalist in the Screenplay Festival, a finalist in the Houston Worldfest, and a semi-finalist in the Filmmakers International. The comment I received from this contest was "Nothing worked for me". All 20 categories were marked "no". Give me a break! Save your money. My script was never even read, or it was read by an idiot.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: Acclaim Film[Post New Comment re: Acclaim Film]

Mark Heidemann Author: Mark Heidemann Posted: 08/31/2005 03:26 PM
Even though I did not make it past the first round, I am delighted with the Acclaim experience. The comments that my script received were sound, professional, and encouraging. I would recommend this contest to everyone.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Alexandria Casey Author: Alexandria Casey Posted: 08/30/2005 12:27 PM
This was such valuable experience! Sasha clearly went above and beyond in her critique; it's obvious that every scene was carefully read and considered. Strengths as well as weaknesses were discussed in full, and some tough criticisms were phrased kindly, but more importantly, constructively. While a win here would have been nice, the specific, balanced, insightful feedback will mean that a win or a sale is so much more likely somewhere down the line. Thanks and kudos to Sasha and all the readers.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Caliann Lum Author: Caliann Lum Posted: 08/27/2005 06:48 PM
I was a quarter-finalist, then a semi-finalist (sequential years). This was enough to get me a read by a top tier agent. I hadn't heard about the competition recently and emailed their office. There's still someone there but they're not currently taking any applications. It's a shame because this competition was, I agree, right up there with Disney, and Nicholl.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: PAGE International[Post New Comment re: PAGE International]

Annie S. Cian Author: Annie S. Cian Posted: 08/27/2005 12:25 PM
My comments are directed to Mr. Sam Glick. All I can say is sour grapes. Just who the hell is he to criticize the other authors for their comments. I would like to know which contest is paying him to put down this rubbish. If he had the balls to enter this contest he would have realized that this is by far the best organized competition in the market with communication and human touch being paramount. He should channel his constipated talents (if he has any) to writing scripts not insulting poison pen notes. And as far as Gil Turner is concerned his articulate comment "yeah" proves that he is the "well-organized scam" as a writer.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Lee Tidball Author: Lee Tidball Posted: 08/27/2005 01:15 AM
My thanks again to the Feeding Frenzy people for another great contest, and that's not just because my script was a Finalist. What was so wonderful again was the invaluable feedback; eight pages of it--this time sent out a full six weeks BEFORE the contest was over--which helped me and my co-writer Ron to work on revisions right away. Insightful, honest, encouraging, Cheryl and Molly really mean it when they say they care and want you to succeed. And how about this, folks! In the era of contests whose deadlines are "extended" interminably and results not announced for months and months with delays and all the rest, this contest posted results A FULL MONTH EARLIER than the original date for winners' announcements! A most pleasantly astonishing surprise from a contest that's already at the top of my list. More bang for your buck than you can imagine, this is a contest not to be missed!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: A Feeding Frenzy[Post New Comment re: A Feeding Frenzy]

Eric Thurschwell Author: Eric Thurschwell Posted: 08/25/2005 07:47 PM
I paid for the minimum (1 page)coverage, and promptly received a 7-page set of helpful development notes from Molly Mayock. The good vibe I got about this contest was confirmed in spades. It's apparently run by genuinely nice, talented people who care about writing and writers, which isn't exactly common in the industry ...

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Teresa Lewis Author: Teresa Lewis Posted: 08/24/2005 03:08 PM
Finally, a contest that treats writers with respect and intelligence. No more "dumbing down" dialogue or avoidance of controversial themes. Sasha Lauren is more than a script reader; she has created more than a mere screenwriting contest. It is only a matter of time before a writer knows that the name Epiphany was not chosen randomly, but seeks and reflects the quality material that transcends the mundane. Any writer entering into Epiphany’s realm will no doubt experience a moment where kind but firm direction will be given, where finally, your voice will be heard. Rebirth has placed as a finalist and Semi-Finalist of many prestigious contests, but never before have I felt so comfortable and challenged. I recommend this contest above all, to any screenwriter who writes with heart, soul and substance. T. L. Lewis Rebirth

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kevin R Crawford Author: Kevin R Crawford Posted: 08/24/2005 02:15 PM
Though I was not a finalist in this contest, Sasha Lauren took great strides to communicate with me about possible markets for my script. Her feedback went above and beyond. Gather up your "brass brads" and put your time and effort into this one! This contest is run by somebody who cares. Bravo Epiphany! Kudos Sasha!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Mike Casey Author: Mike Casey Posted: 08/24/2005 01:14 PM
This contest sets the standard by which I will judge all future competitions. Sasha Lauren did not simply read my screenplay, she invested herself in it. Her friendly, professional manner, combined with abundant no-nonsense, insightful critical feedback, made this a truly worthwhile experience for this writer. MSC

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Cheryl Compton Author: Cheryl Compton Posted: 08/23/2005 02:33 PM
I couldn't agree more with the above posts. Epiphany has gone above and beyond any screenplay contest we have ever entered. With most contests, you're lucky if you get more than two sentences of feedback. Even then, it's difficult to tell if they've read past the first 10 pages. Sasha Lauren really took an interest in our script and has helped us to make it better. She is very interested in our creative future. Epiphany is more than worth every cent of the application fee. Thank you again, Sasha!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Jonathan Sloate Author: Jonathan Sloate Posted: 08/22/2005 09:29 PM
This is a terrific contest to enter. Sasha Lauren specifically called me up and spoke to me over the phone giving me very useful construction criticism to improve my screenplays.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Don Macnab-Stark Author: Don Macnab-Stark Posted: 08/19/2005 09:08 AM
My commetns relate to the 2005 contest. The deadlines were adhered to, and the level of feedback showed that the script had been not only read, but thoroughly analysed. Given the cost of professional feedback, this contest is excellent value for money. I would certainly enter again next year.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Paul Hall Author: Paul Hall Posted: 08/18/2005 09:55 PM
I entered four scripts in the Blue Cat Contest and was extremely satisfied. Listed below is a copy of a brief note of thanks I wrote to Gordy Hoffman for the extensive critiques of my work.

Mr. Gordy Hoffman: Even though you have wrecked my writing schedule for the next six months or so, I'm writing to let you know how valuable your critiques of the four screenplays I entered in the Blue Cat Screenplay Competition are. The hell of it is that, for the most part, I agree with your evaluations, particularly my thriller AVENGED. I have already begun the dismemberment. I was pleased at your enthusiasm for Connelly and Lenny (MINOR DEATHS), and your laudatory "The script is a well written gritty cop drama." However, I share your feeling that the storyline is toooooooo familiar. You're also pretty much on the money with my two romantic comedies. Thanks to your comments, I anticipate that I can handle the problems. May our paths cross again sometime in the future.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Jorge J. Lomastro Author: Jorge J. Lomastro Posted: 08/18/2005 01:34 PM
I don't make a habit of posting comments. So, a screenwriter might want to take note. With all due respect to the few positive statements, I will PASS on this contest in the future and would suggest the same to others. i.e. Writer beware.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: PAGE International[Post New Comment re: PAGE International]

Kevin R Crawford Author: Kevin R Crawford Posted: 08/18/2005 01:13 AM
Very pleased with the communication between writer and contest runners on this one! PAGE takes the time to honor its entrants with the kind of feedback young writers need in order to judge their place in the field. The judging is according to genre categories, and is much fairer in a contest market whose readership traditionally tends to favor only "dramas" and "comedies". No matter where your story passions lie, definitely sink your "brass brads" into this one!

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Kevin R Crawford Author: Kevin R Crawford Posted: 08/17/2005 11:52 PM
While I would rate the prestige and significance of this contest quite high, I found the lack of feedback totally inexcusable for a competition of this caliber. "Six" fabulous finalists suddenly appear in cyberspace (today) out of thousands of submissions and these guys don't have the courtesy to let anybody no how high or how close their entries placed in relation to the "top six" they reported on. This competition (like other well-run contests) should give rankings as a range . . . i.e., quaterfinalists, semifinalists out of such a large field of entries. They take your money and don't even care to honor the rest of the writers by presenting a statistical grid. You submit, enter and walk-away blind in this contest -- unless of course you are one of the top six. C'mon people, how hard is it to tell us how many entries you received and offer a little data so writer's can really gauge themselves against the field. There are many writers out there who have found representation or got scripts optioned at even the quarterfinal level. (P.S. on the same day I received notification of the "finalists" for this contest they sent me three emails telling my scripts were read "two" months ago. Go figure! I DON'T recommend this contest, and feel it's a poor reflection upon the "Writer's Store" as principal sponsor. Sorry guys, but you can do better than this.)

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Theresa Hart Author: Theresa Hart Posted: 08/15/2005 02:13 PM
Expiration date was orginally April 15th. Then they kept extending it till July 20th. Why? To make more money? They didn't get enough response? To make more money? :-(

Then posted semi-finalist/finalist and winner at same time on the site. Gave no notification on this contest via email.

I paid extra for late submission for April 15th deadline then if you submitted after the first late deadline *April 15th* the rate was cheaper. I don't trust any contest that keeps extending their deadlines for for 3 extra months.

They never sent a email saying anything about ANYTHING.

I wouldn't waste my time or money entering this contest again.

But I hope the winners get their chance to make it. Good luck.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Jana Dilworth Author: Jana Dilworth Posted: 08/10/2005 02:42 AM
I encourage every aspiring writer -novice or considered expert to enter this contest. I was neither a winner or a runner-up. In all honesty, I entered this contest strictly for the feedback. It was everything the organizers stated and more. The feedback was detailed and right one. I was also pleasantly surprised at the length of the detail. I expected a couple of paragraphs for $25 and received six full ones of honest constructive criticism. I've already started the rewrites. Congratulations to all of the Bluecat winners, past and present. I hope to join that list one day. P.S. My friend had to change his email address, so Bluecat had his old one, we emailed Gordy once the feedback rolled in and Gordy immediately responded to his new email address with his feedback. This organization cares about writers.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: American Gem Short[Post New Comment re: American Gem Short]

Kevin R Crawford Author: Kevin R Crawford Posted: 08/09/2005 11:47 AM
Very impressed! American Gem goes the extra mile to keep you informed every step of the way with personal and global email alerts. Timely. Professional. Writer-driven. An affirming experience for the beginning writer. Highly recommended.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: American Gem Short[Post New Comment re: American Gem Short]

Martine Meah Author: Martine Meah Posted: 07/29/2005 01:03 PM
This is an excellent competition. It's a real confidence boost to receive their fantastic e-mails congragulating you each time you make it into another round.

It really makes you feel that you're not just a number and it's that personal touch that makes all the difference. They seem genuinely excited to announce you've been placed in their competition.

I will definitely be entering this competition in the future and would recommend it to other budding writers.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: FilmMakers[Post New Comment re: FilmMakers]

Larry Williams Author: Larry Williams Posted: 07/23/2005 03:15 PM
Seems very professional. Timely notification and more contest stage announcements than most contests: i.e. top 425, top 200, top 100, top 50, top 20, winners.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Marjory Kaptanoglu Author: Marjory Kaptanoglu Posted: 07/23/2005 12:20 PM
I am a relatively new screenwriter and this is the first time I have entered the Blue Cat contest (2005). I was neither a winner nor a runner-up. However, I would happily enter this contest again for the following reasons: winners were announced on the promised dates, I received feedback via email within 5 days after that, and the cost was only $25 (for paper submissions). Moreover, the feedback showed a careful reading of the script. It was generous in its praise (I can’t help liking that), and accurate, I think, in pointing out those areas that need improvement. It was also encouraging to receive a total point score that was only 3 points less than that received by last year’s winner. If I could suggest any improvement, it would be for Blue Cat to publish a quarterfinalist/semifinalist list as well, because such credits are helpful to struggling writers. As it is, Blue Cat listed five finalists and five honorable mentions out of over 1000 entries this year. That means you have to be in the top 1% to get mentioned at all. Many contests recognize at least the top 5%, and sometimes the top 10%.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: FilmMakers[Post New Comment re: FilmMakers]

Gregory Field Author: Gregory Field Posted: 07/21/2005 05:07 PM
I'm a new writer, and new to the competition world. I don't have personal knowledge whether Filmmakers reads the entire script or not, but they've kept their word on meeting posting deadlines, so I'm going to error on the side of integrity and assume they do.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: BlueCat Contest[Post New Comment re: BlueCat Contest]

Roy Blixen Author: Roy Blixen Posted: 07/20/2005 12:43 AM
I submitted my first screenplay, which Gordy judged to be little more than a rough outline of a screenplay. Next year I entered another, and surprise, the critique indicated improvement. 2005 was my third script...and guess what, still improving. I use the Blucat as a indicator of how I am progressing.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Judy Bednarek Author: Judy Bednarek Posted: 07/15/2005 08:42 PM
I received a bulk postcard today dated June 2005 (It's July 15). My script did not make the semi-finals but it was my impression from their website that ALL ENTRIES would receive feedback or an evaluation from judges. It was one of the reasons why I entered the contest. I sent an email requesting my feedback. I'll post if I hear back from them.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

JUSTIN SWINGLE Author: JUSTIN SWINGLE Posted: 07/08/2005 09:18 AM
The day AFTER the deadline for this competition they announced by automatic email reply that the competition was "cancelled" and that scripts and refunds were in the mail. Now more than four weeks later there has been NO REFUND/RETURN OF MONEY ORDER or SCRIPTS RETURNED. I am filing a MAIL FRAUD COMPLAINT with the USPOST OFFICE.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Mark Foster Author: Mark Foster Posted: 06/27/2005 10:18 PM
I had the feeling that my script was never read. I sent it and post-marked it on May 31, the final day of the contest. With mail time built in, they probably got the script 3 to 4 days later. The winners were announced on June 15, and they had been accepting scripts for several months before that. My bad for not getting it in earlier, but I did abide by the rules, yet I feel that they had already trimmed down their list to finalists by the time my script was received. Of course, the check cashed on time...

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Hilary Downes Author: Hilary Downes Posted: 06/23/2005 01:17 PM
LAME! They were happy to accept my $60 screenplay submission fee, but fail to maintain a functional email address for receiving scripts or correspondence, and the only phone number I found for them online (not on their website, I might add) was incorrect.

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]

Contest: [Post New Comment re: ]

Catherine Paul Author: Catherine Paul Posted: 06/11/2005 07:09 PM
I entered my screenplay UPRISING in the Expo 4 Screenplay Competition contest in, I think October, 2004(the only contest I entered) and it was a great experience! After I recv'd an honorable mention in the action-adventure genre, I recv'd requests for a copy of the script from a variety of well-known prodcos.

I fully recommend this contest for anybody who knows that their script is ready to be read by top-notch prodcos.

I am currently working on another script and hope to have it ready in time for the 2005 entry deadline!

Catherine Paul

[Display All Contest Comments by this Author]
(Displaying records 2201 thru 2300 of 2709 records)
Results Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23  | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 |