Screenwriting Contest Advice
Subscribe to the MovieBytes Screenwriting Contest Newsletter for weekly deadline alerts and other screenplay contest news!
Is Contest Feedback Worthwhile?
By Jerry Traynor, Associate Editor, Moviebytes.com
Aspiring screenwriters are often drawn to screenwriting contests, hoping to gain recognition, industry access, and valuable feedback. Many competitions offer script evaluations as part of their entry fee, while others charge extra for more detailed coverage. But are these contests truly a good source of feedback? The answer largely depends on the contest, the writer’s expectations, and what they hope to gain from the experience.
One of the main advantages of screenwriting contests is that they provide an external perspective on a script. Writers can become too close to their work, making it difficult to see structural flaws or underdeveloped characters. A contest judge or reader, approaching the script with fresh eyes, may highlight issues the writer hadn’t considered. This can be especially useful for newer writers who haven’t yet built a network of trusted peers or professionals to critique their work.
However, the quality of feedback varies widely. Some contests employ experienced industry professionals, while others rely on junior readers or interns with limited expertise. High-profile competitions, such as the Nicholl Fellowship or the Austin Film Festival, tend to have more seasoned readers, making their notes more insightful. Smaller contests, on the other hand, may not have the same level of rigor, which can lead to inconsistent or even superficial feedback.
Another potential issue is that feedback from contests often lacks depth. Many competitions provide only a few paragraphs of analysis, which may not be enough for a writer looking for in-depth guidance. A note about a character feeling “underdeveloped” or dialogue seeming “unnatural” is useful only if it comes with clear explanations and actionable suggestions. Without this, the feedback can feel vague or even frustrating, leaving the writer unsure of how to improve their script.
The subjectivity of contest feedback is another factor to consider. Screenwriting is an art, and different readers will interpret scripts in different ways. One reader might love a script’s originality, while another might see it as too unconventional. Some contests provide multiple evaluations from different readers, which can help balance out subjective opinions, but many do not. Writers who receive conflicting feedback may struggle to determine which notes to take seriously.
Cost is another consideration. Screenwriting contests can be expensive, with entry fees ranging from $40 to over $100. Feedback services often come at an additional cost, making it an expensive way to receive notes. Professional script consultants or coverage services may charge more, but they typically provide more thorough and personalized analysis. Writers should weigh whether contest feedback is worth the investment compared to alternative options, such as hiring a consultant, joining a writers’ group, or participating in workshops.
Despite these concerns, contests can still be valuable if approached with the right mindset. If a writer views contests primarily as a way to gain exposure or advance their career, then feedback is simply an added bonus. Some competitions, particularly those with industry connections, offer mentorships, networking opportunities, and introductions to agents or producers, which can be far more beneficial than the feedback itself.
Ultimately, screenwriting contests can be a useful source of feedback, but they should not be relied upon as the sole means of improving a script. Writers should research contests carefully, consider the reputation of their readers, and evaluate whether the feedback aligns with their goals. While some contests provide constructive and insightful critiques, others may offer only surface-level comments that do little to help a writer grow. The best approach is to view contest feedback as one of many tools in the revision process, rather than a definitive judgment on a script’s quality.
ScriptLinks
Post Your Script Here!One, Second Summer (Young Adult/Romance/Sci-Fi/Dramedy)
Second Summer on Cape Cod is usually a quiet time, until a spaceship of wacky extraterrestrials come to visit, and two fearless tween-agers, determined to meet them, find out why.
Bewitching Hitler: The Coven that Beat the Nazis and Saved the Wolrd! (Historical Fiction/Dramedy/Romance - based on actual events.)
A plucky UK/New Forest Witch Coven conjures an ancient magic spell to prevent Hitler from winning World War II.
Illicit
In a daring escape from their high-stakes corporate lives and familial responsibilities, two married executives find themselves entangled in a passionate affair at an upscale hotel.
Beyond Forever
Reeling from a devastating personal tragedy, a man abandons his successful career, family, and friends to embark on a one-way journey to Mars through an avant-garde space exploration initiative.
BOOM!Town (Parody of Crime/Mob Story/Dramedy)
After a bloody car bombing, a blown-off human foot lands on the roof of a retired, cash-poor mob cleaner who schemes to extort the Mafia Don that ordered the hit, unaware his wacky plan may help the FBI catch the cut-throat gangster.
My Name is Wallace (Romantic Comedy/Differently-Abled/Dramedy)
A lonely, autistic man misunderstands a computer ad, connects to a fantasy-sex site, and falls in love.
MAD DADDY! (Historical Fiction/BIO/Dramedy)
A wildly talented, schizophrenic 1950s rock deejay—at the height of his radio success—contemplates suicide, then faces intervention by a series of ghosts from his past.
Happy New Year, Mr. Kates! (Hoilday/Dramedy/Magical Realism)
A contemporary holiday tale about a grumpy old man who resides in the memory unit of nursing home, and is presented with a gripping bargain by a mystical stranger: the chance to swap his inconsequential life for that of a lost child’s, one snowy New Year's Eve.
The Confession (Elevated Horror/Drama/Thriller)
A shy eight-year-old Catholic girl commits a petty crime to have a
Radioland! (Coming of Age/Psychological/Comedy/Drama/Memoir
A naïve 12-year-old boy, falls in love with a fantasy, learns the truth about his fatally flawed hero -- a 1960s Top 40 radio deejay -- and discovers the bittersweet